Category Archives: News

Vancouver Island

Oil Spill Response Shows British Columbia Government Failings

 The three founders are aware of the importance of providing environmentally friendly solutions to society. Dragon Sorb has a great deal of experience in handling accidental offshore and onshore spills of oils and chemicals

In 2012, the B.C. government established five situations that had to be achieved before the province would support two proposed pipelines, which would greatly increase tanker traffic to the West Coast.

Number two on that list was the establishment of the “world-leading marine oil spill reaction, prevention and recovery technique.”

Grounding of the Nathan E. Stewart

Unfortunately, in the last seven days, the lack of forward movement on that point was strongly underlined when U.S.-registered tug Nathan E. Stewart ran aground while pushing a massive gasoline barge inside a narrow passage just north of Bella Bella.

Bella Bella, British ColumbiaThankfully for the Terrific Bear Rainforest and the Heiltsuk people who reside there, barge DBL 55 was empty. But an incident report filed in 2011 by the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation offers a view of how serious the accident might have been, had the 289-foot (91-metre) fuel barge been loaded.

On Dec. 21 of that year, precisely the same tug and barge went adrift just after engine failure in the vicinity of Cape Fairweather, in the Gulf of Alaska.

The following report stated that the tug had 45,000 (170m3) gallons of diesel and 500 (1.9m3) gallons of lube oil on board. The cargo on board the fuel barge was 2.2 million (83,279m3) gallons of diesel fuel, 1,028 (3.9m3) gallons of aviation gasoline, and 700 (2.65m3) gallons of other petroleum products.

In that incident, no oil was spilled after both the tug and barge were towed to safety.

The Sinking of the Nathan E. Stewart

In the Bella Bella accident the barge that ran aground on a reef was refloated. However, the tug sank, haemorrhaging diesel and other petroleum products. Long before spill response staff arrived from Prince Rupert, a gasoline slick had passed through Gale Pass into a region famous for its abundant clam beds and highly-valued by the Heiltsuk .

Head of the Heiltsuk people, Marilyn Slett, stated that although the tug crew, Coast Guard responders and local volunteers did try to contain the fuel, they lacked sufficient equipment. A reaction crew was dispatched from Prince Rupert, but was more than 20 hours away . The day after the accident, Ms. Slett was still waiting for the spill to be contained.

Slow Going for the Cleanup Effort

Ms. Slett claimed that the experience of the cleanup effort had been a frustrating procedure. She said that here were a lot of people milling about, going into and out of meetings, but when she talked to her people on the ground, the whole process was extremely sluggish. When it came right down to the ‘world-class, oil-spill response’, it just did not come about.

Ms. Slett added that it had been an annoying attempting to get the system mobilised. Ms. Slett also said that it would probably be some time prior before they understood how badly the clam waters were polluted.

Judging from heavy odour of diesel on the garments of the Heiltsuk volunteers who had come back from the spill sites, she appeared deeply anxious.

The Dangers of Large Gasoline Barges

Ingmar Lee, an environmental activist who lives on Denny Island in close proximity to Bella Bella, has been warning for several years about the large gasoline barges meandering up and down the coast of British Columbia.

British Columbia

He had especially been voicing his worries concerning the Nathan E. Stewart, which he first encountered some years ago as it was pushing the DBL 55 through Fitzhugh Sound, south of Bella Bella. He was shocked at the dimensions of the barge and thought it risky for a vessel of that size to be navigating the narrow Inside Passage.

He said that only one small error, a power failure or something similar and within minutes, you could be on the rocks.

The crew of the Nathan E. Stewart learned that the hard way last Thursday.

The Expansion of the Pipelines

The response of the spill that followed is a long way from what B.C. should offer, especially in respect to the rise in tanker traffic that will arrive if either of Enbridge’s Northern Gateway project, or Kinder Morgan’s Trans Mountain pipeline expansion go ahead.

Responding to the tug and barge incident, Premier Christy Clark explained that she had argued for five years that the spill reaction was thoroughly insufficient, not just from the point of view of the future pipelines coming from Alberta, but also from what was going up and down the coastline at the moment. She also agree with the critics, saying that there comments about the spill were very appropriate.

When the pipelines are in place, there will be a lot more tankers on the coast. The government has recognised this for many years but has not, as of yet, put in position the “world-class” oil spill management that British Columbia first mooted in 2012.

A final decision about the proposed $6.8-billion Trans Mountain pipeline is expected by the Federal Cabinet in December. Last June, the Federal Court of Appeal overturned federal approval of the $7.9-billion Northern Gateway challenge after ruling that Ottawa had not adequately consulted the First Nation people.

Source article:  B.C. government’s lack of progress on oil spill response highlighted by tug accident

Australian Oil Company Sued By Indonesian Seaweed Farmers

Over 13,000 Indonesian seaweed farmers have launched an enormous action in Australia’s federal court demanding compensation for the outcomes of Australia’s worst oil spill.

In August 2009, there was an enormous explosion at an oil well in Australian waters in the Timor Sea. The well was operated by a subsidiary on the state-owned Thai oil business, PTT Exploration and Production Public Company (PTTEP). For over ten weeks between 3,776 to 28,323 tonnes of oil spilled into the sea.

In September, 2009 things started to change. Indonesian seaweed farmers on Rote Island, 250km away, said the disaster had devastated their livelihood. According to one eye witness, the water was multi-coloured and the seaweed started to change colour as well. At the time, there were also many dead fish. Over the next four years all the seaweed they had planted died.

Seaweed Farmers


The Seaweed Farmers’ Lawyer

Australian lawyers are seeking about A$200m for seaweed farmers that have suffered as a result of Australia’s largest oil spill. Lawyer Greg Phelps was quoted as saying that it may seem like a lot of money but there are many seaweed farmers and the seaweed farmers had enterprises with returns of as much as A$30,000 a year, also stating that A$30,000 was an appreciable amount of money when considering the local economic system.

According to the BBC, Mr Phelps made the decision to get on the situation soon after travelling to Rote Island and listening to the seaweed farmers’ stories. He suggested that the stories recounted by the farmers were compelling and it became obvious to him that a really substantial area had been affected by a huge amount of pollution. Lawyers are suing PTTEP Australasia, a subsidiary of PTTEP.

The Response by PTTEP Australasia

PTTEP Australasia has given a statement saying it paid for the largest unbiased scientific analysis application ever undertaken into the Timor Sea environment. This confirmed that no oil from the spill landed on the shores of Indonesia. PTTEP Australasia also stated that there was no lasting impact to the extremely delicate and biodiverse ecosystems in the areas closest to Indonesian waters, although none of its studies or tests was actually done in Indonesian waters or around Rote.

PTTEP Australasia stated that it was fair to extrapolate. The studies showed that the reefs closest to Montara had no lasting negative impacts. As this was where the oil and dispersant concentrations were at their highest, it would be highly improbable that the shoreline of Nusa Tenggara Timor (NTT) would have been more impacted.

Rote Island and Northern Australia

Indonesia is among the top seaweed producers. Farmers on Rote were earning more than they ever thought possible. In some cases over A$20,000 per annum – a staggeringly large amount of money considering the island’s economic climate.

Indonesian activist Ferdi Tanoni has for several years fruitlessly lobbied both the Indonesian and Australian governments and also PTTEP Australasia to fund a proper environmental evaluation on the effects of the oil spill. For him, the truth that the situation is currently in court is actually a victory.

Ferdi stated that the seaweed farmers now have allies all over the environment and that he had faith in the justice system in Australia. However, the legal system in Australia is as slow as anywhere else in the world. Lawyers are warning that the situation could drag on for months or maybe years.

Please note: Dragon Sorb in no way intends to apportion blame and this article is for informational use only.